Become a member and gain unlimited access to content, courses, and webinars.
The Love & Respect

Membership

$249
$199/y

Unlimited Access To All Our Content

Inside The Love & Respect Membership

  • L&R Conference 10 Week Study Included ($149 value)
  • 14 Online Courses!
  • Access over 930+ Articles
  • Weekly Podcast - 270+ Episodes
  • Ask Emerson - 180+ Videos
  • Collections - 18 Curated Topics
  • Devotional - 52 Videos, Prayer, To-Do
  • Webinars Throughout The Year
and more to come...
Return to the homepage
Christian Life
Image duration icon
15
min
Favorite
Favorite
Oops! Something went wrong.
Favorite

Unveiling the Secrets of Why, How, and When to Give Thanks (Part 2): It’s Time to Gauge Your Gratitude

Play Arrow
Watch Intro Video

Because you have read to this point, I know you take seriously the importance of the title of this short series: “Reimagining Gratitude: Unveiling the Secrets of Why, How, and When to Give Thanks.” Perhaps you learned these truths earlier in life. Still, this series serves as a reminder that ignites your imagination in a new manner. Or, perhaps for the first time, you are exploring the redefinition of giving thanks. Some of this examination throws new light on gratitude for you, but you may feel ambivalent or reluctant, or so you think you are.

Are you interested in an invitation to assess yourself? In other words, if asked why, how, and when you give thanks, what would you answer?

Let’s get specific on ten statements where I ask if you agree or disagree with the statement. On a scale of 1 to 5, what would be your answer?

Record your rating for each of the ten statements using this scale:

  • 1. Strongly Disagree
  • 2. Disagree
  • 3. Neutral
  • 4. Agree
  • 5. Strongly Agree

I. If Asked Why I Give Thanks, I Would Say:

A. “Giving thanks is God’s will for me.”

B. “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving.”

C. “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength.”

D. “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude.”

E. “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions.”

F. “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace.”

II. If Asked How to Give Thanks, I Would Say:

A. “By praying.”

B. “By focusing on Christ.”

III. If Asked When to Give Thanks, I Would Say:

A. “In all circumstances.”

B. “In plenty and poverty.”

Now tabulate your answers and write your total score.

Which of the three below clusters does your score place you in?

  • The Reluctant Person (10-20)
  • The Ambivalent Person (21-39)
  • The Committed Person (40-50).

The Reluctant Person is unbelieving, resistant, or defiant about giving thanks, and the reason for this reluctance is something only they can answer. At this juncture in their spiritual journey, they either struggle to trust what God says in Scripture about giving thanks or are unwilling to believe it. They may either quietly resist the teaching or openly defy God’s call to give thanks.

I use the term “Reluctant,” because it is important to extend grace and patience to the person, as they have felt run over by some circumstantial boulder—such as losing a five-year-old child to cancer—that has led to their current struggle and stumbling. Therefore, I wish to give them my understanding and empathy. In these circumstances, our loving Lord would see this reluctance as temporary. As was the case with Job and Job’s wife, who lost everything, including his health, God gives time to process the tragedy. Job teaches us that this reluctance to bless the Lord and give thanks may be evidence of disobedience and defiance. He humbly told his wife she reacted foolishly against God. Job’s wife did not appear to seek recovery, but she chose to shake her fist at heaven, which we observe when she commands Job to curse God and die. The Reluctant Person must weigh humbly if the long-term posture is beyond a seasonal reluctance and they have entered a condition of rebellion.

The Ambivalent Person ultimately stands in the land of doubt, indecision, and indifference about gratitude and the giving of thanks. For some time, they have resided in a spiritual realm where they position one foot in Scripture, which calls them to give thanks, but another foot lands in a field that mocks the notion of offering a sacrifice of praise. In facing the voices in both territories, calling them to give thanks and calling them to refuse to give thanks, they turn agnostic. They do not know which “truth claim” to believe, so they resort to “I don’t know what to believe anymore.”

Though the Bible calls them to give thanks to God in all circumstances because this is His will, they hear the dogmatic assertions of liberal theologians and secularists who declare that such thanksgiving should be diagnosed as a sign of insanity. Thus, in hearing these contradictory appeals, this person ends up standing in a third territory: the state of ambivalence. They are doubtful about the wisdom of giving thanks in that they hear that they would be giving thanks for evil, and it would be silly and ineffective to give thanks despite the evil. As time passes, and they remain indecisive, they grow indifferent. They do not denounce those who give thanks; however, they no longer care about being grateful to God no matter the circumstance. In such a condition, they could be the type of person Jesus called lukewarm. They are not hot or cold on the extremes about giving or not giving thanks. Instead, they lack interest and excitement. In one sense, the profile of the Ambivalent may be darker than that of the Reluctant, who is hot or cold against the idea of thanksgiving. The Ambivalent have chosen to distrust and disobey but do not discern this. They do not detect the seriousness of their lukewarmness and indifference.

The Committed Person exemplifies trust, resolution, and ardency. By reading Scripture that illumines and inspires them, they grow in their trust of God as part of their daily walk in giving Him thanks. They have planted their feet firmly on the ground of God’s inherent goodness, faithfulness, and love. Yes, they recognize that the daily grind, which entails facing the reality of evil and suffering, ignites questions that the Lord won’t always answer. Despite the unanswered questions, they have decided to trust Him based on what they understand of His goodness, faithfulness, and love. For this reason, they can echo the unwavering faith of Job, who spoke, “Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him” (Job 13:15 KJV). Paul reiterates this truth when writing to Rome’s persecuted and suffering church: “For I am convinced that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor any other created thing, will be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 8:38-39). The Committed Person is convinced of God’s sovereign character. Due to this trust, they remain resolute and unwavering, like Job. No matter the outcome, they trust, praise, thank, bless, and worship God. They work diligently at this since such gratitude expressed as “I thank You, Lord, no matter what” does not emerge from the soul naturally. The default posture is fear, doubt, and anger.

By faith and determination, the Committed Person believes all things work together for good (Romans 8:28), even though some are led to the slaughter like lambs (Romans 8:36). Beyond the commitment to trust and be resolute, they strive to be positively emotional about this. Being ardent signifies their wholehearted and enthusiastic commitment to giving thanks. They do not deny the misery and mistreatment. However, they enter the spiritual discipline of keeping a gratitude journal, which records the positive things for which they give thanks. They focus on anticipating God’s goodness in working everything together for good. In prayer, they express their confidence, with thanksgiving, that God is at work even if they never see it. Concerning the people they fellowship with, they are givers of thanks. As a work in progress, they do not beat themselves up when they fail to give thanks during a tough and rough day; but as they remember, they offer the sacrifice of praise even when not feeling it. Because of their gratitude journal, they also pen their giving of thanks in anticipation of God’s actions and then celebrate the answers they observe. Thus, they are committed givers of thanks. They display trust, resolution, and ardency.

I. The Reluctant Person to Give Thanks (a score of 10-20)

Why is this person reluctant to give thanks? As an unbelieving, resistant, or defiant person, this soul disagrees or strongly disagrees with several, if not all, of these six statements:

  • “Giving thanks is God’s will for me.”
  • “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving.”
  • “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength.”
  • “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude.”
  • “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions.”
  • “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace.”

How is this person reluctant to give thanks? As an unbelieving, resistant, or defiant person, this soul likely disagrees or strongly disagrees with giving thanks in these two ways:

  • Giving thanks by praying
  • Giving thanks by focusing on Christ

When is this person reluctant to give thanks? As an unbelieving, resistant, or defiant person, this soul likely disagrees or strongly disagrees with giving thanks at these times:

  • Giving thanks in all circumstances
  • Giving thanks in plenty and poverty

II. The Ambivalent Person to Give Thanks (a score of 21-39)

Why is this person ambivalent about giving thanks? As a doubtful, indecisive, or indifferent person, this soul is neutral about several, if not all, of these six statements:

  • “Giving thanks is God’s will for me.”
  • “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving.”
  • “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength.”
  • “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude.”
  • “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions.”
  • “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace.”

How is this person ambivalent about giving thanks? As a doubtful, indecisive, or indifferent person, this soul is neutral about giving thanks in these two ways:

  • Giving thanks by praying
  • Giving thanks by focusing on Christ

When is this person ambivalent about giving thanks? As a doubtful, indecisive, or indifferent person, this soul is neutral about giving thanks at these two times:

  • Giving thanks in all circumstances
  • Giving thanks in plenty and poverty

III. The Committed Person to Give Thanks (a score of 40-50)

Why is this person committed to giving thanks? As a trusting, resolved, and ardent person, this soul agrees or strongly agrees with several, if not all, of these six statements:

  • “Giving thanks is God’s will for me.”
  • “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving.”
  • “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength.”
  • “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude.”
  • “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions.”
  • “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace.”

How is this person committed to giving thanks? As a trusting, resolved, and ardent person, this soul agrees or strongly agrees with giving thanks in these two ways:

  • Giving thanks by praying
  • Giving thanks by focusing on Christ

When is this person committed to giving thanks? As a trusting, resolved, and ardent person, this soul agrees or strongly agrees with giving thanks at these two times:

  • Giving thanks in all circumstances
  • Giving thanks in plenty and poverty

In general, the answers to the why determine the answers to the how and when. The person reluctant to give thanks, because they disagree with God’s inspired reasons, will more than likely disagree with God’s inspired methods and moments.

The person ambivalent about giving thanks because they are neutral toward God’s inspired reasons will likely be neutral toward God’s inspired methods and moments.

And, the person committed to giving thanks, because they agree with God’s inspired reasons, will more than likely agree with God’s inspired methods and moments.

What is the implication for each group?

For the Reluctant Person:

May I invite you to consider several steps forward, given you wish to move from the reluctant giver of thanks to the committed person who gives thanks?

1. Please consider the reasons for being reluctant. Why might you be unbelieving, resistant, or defiant?

There were reasons you said “strongly disagree” or “disagree.” Are you in tune with those reasons?

In part 1, I highlighted some categories in which some believers find themselves disturbed and de-energized related to giving thanks. Almost inevitably, there is one negative factor that feels like it is sucking the life out of the soul. Please review the topics I mentioned. Is something blocking you from giving thanks maritally, financially, medically, emotionally, parentally, generationally, vocationally, theologically, demonically, prayerfully, and comparatively?

2. Please consider discussing this reason with a godly, wise person who has struggled with a similar matter but who gives thanks—someone like my wife, Sarah. Sarah would be non-judgmental but honest about the importance of addressing the underlying blockage to giving thanks or offering a sacrifice of praise. For example, she might say, “I have learned this is an act of obedience apart from feeling thankful. That’s why it is a sacrifice of praise. It is a sacrifice to do this when not feeling like doing this.”

Talk through your reluctance in the following areas:

  • “Giving thanks is God’s will for me”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks by praying”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks by focusing on Christ”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks in all circumstances”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)
  • “I give thanks in plenty and poverty”: 1 (Strongly Disagree), 2 (Disagree)

3. Please consider resources on the giving of thanks. This topic is commonly addressed in books, sermons, or podcasts since God’s Word inundates us with the call to give thanks.

4. Please start small. Years ago, a person who had been subjected to satanic ritualistic abuse came to me for pastoral counsel. In that discussion, I said, “Have you ever given thanks for the suffering?” She thought me crazy and was disturbed by my suggestion. She returned the next week, and I recommended that she begin small during that time. “Lord, would You make me willing to give thanks?” That advice changed her forever. She said, “I can do that.” From there, God mercifully took her by the hand as she prayed, “Make me willing to be willing to give thanks.” My mom used to say, “God can do a lot with a little if He has all of it.”

For the Ambivalent Person:

1. Please consider the reasons for being ambivalent. Jesus said that He preferred a person to be hot or cold but not lukewarm. Given the “neutral” category captured most of your answers, was that due to feeling, in short, “I have not cared much”? If so, please get in tune with your lukewarmness. That may not be a good thing, and is actually more reluctant than you imagine.

2. Please clarify what you believe. Perhaps you remain neutral because you do not know how you feel or what you believe. I invite you to look again at these scriptures. Are they God-inspired? Do you have a neutral posture due to double-mindedness about what you believe in the Bible? A man who straddles the fence hurts himself. He should stop straddling. He needs to land on one side or the other but not rest there since it will not be very restful. This Likert Scale has likely brought you to a crossroads to finally decide to give thanks in faith, like Sarah, my wife. Assuming you have a deep desire to trust Christ, giving thanks enables us to do that and reveals to ourselves that we do trust Him as good, faithful, and loving despite the circumstances.

3. Please experiment—purely and in small ways, not by testing God in unholy ways—by giving thanks for the good and the less-than-good things. By less than good, I mean thank God for whatever since you choose to believe He causes all things to work together for good according to Romans 8:28. Thank Him for His desire to work together for good, something that troubles you maritally, financially, medically, emotionally, parentally, generationally, vocationally, theologically, demonically, prayerfully, or comparatively.

We must explore and experiment as believers, not to make God prove Himself but for us to prove to ourselves and Him that we no longer intend to be neutral or ambivalent since straddling the fence is never comfortable.

4. Please journal your findings and meet with a godly, wise person who may have voiced their ambivalence about giving thanks. Please talk about your experience with the expectation of moving into a more committed practice of offering a sacrifice of praise like my wife learned to do. Remember, this is not natural. The only thing really natural is giving thanks for winning the lottery.

As you discuss with this person your ambivalence, discuss each of the reasons behind your “neutral” ratings for God’s inspired why, how, and when.

For the Committed Person:

1. Please celebrate your commitment. This is no small spiritual discipline. Honestly, you are pleasing the Lord.

The giving of thanks scores high with the Lord. Do you recall when Jesus healed the ten men of leprosy? Luke 17:16-17 states that after the healing they departed but only one returned who “fell on his face at His feet, giving thanks to Him. And he was a Samaritan. But Jesus responded and said, ‘Were there not ten cleansed? But the nine—where are they?’”

Imagine not giving thanks to Jesus for the healing! Imagine more so how we please Him when offering a sacrifice of praise on the heels of unanswered prayers and questions. For you to do this places you in a special camp.

2. Please consider sharing with others what you are learning about giving of thanks. You need not preach but give voice to how you face the daily struggles of life. People look for authenticity. Many believers want to give thanks since they know this is God’s will, but they have few models. Be a model who mentors.

3. Please think through and provide examples or explanations that can help others do what you do in the below areas:

  • “Giving thanks is God’s will for me.”
  • “I give thanks because I know God is good, faithful, and loving.”
  • “I have the capacity to give thanks, doing so through Christ’s strength.”
  • “I give thanks as evidence of my growing faith and gratitude.”
  • “My thanksgiving precedes my petitions.”
  • “My giving thanks leads to the experience of God’s peace.”
  • “I give thanks by praying.”
  • “I give thanks by focusing on Christ.”
  • “I give thanks in all circumstances.”
  • “I give thanks in plenty and poverty.”

In conclusion, use this checklist on giving thanks to improve one to three areas.

If Asked Why I Give Thanks, My Answer is:

“I know this is God’s will for me.”

Be thankful in all circumstances, for this is God’s will for you who belong to Christ Jesus. (1 Thessalonians 5:18 NLT)

“I know who God is: always good, faithful, and loving.”

Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good! His faithful love endures forever. (Psalm 107:1 NLT)

“I have the capacity to give thanks, plus Christ strengthens me to give thanks.”

I can do everything through Christ, who gives me strength. (Philippians 4:13 NLT)

“Because gratitude should precede petition.”

Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. (Philippians 4:6)

“It evidences my growing faith and gratitude.”

Let your roots grow down into him, and let your lives be built on him. Then your faith will grow strong in the truth you were taught, and you will overflow with thankfulness. (Colossians 2:7 NLT)

“It leads to the experience of God’s peace.”

And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus. (Philippians 4:7)

If Asked How to Give Thanks, My Answer is:

“By praying.”

Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus. (Philippians 4:6-7)

“By focusing on Christ.”

Let your roots grow down into him, and let your lives be built on him. Then your faith will grow strong in the truth you were taught, and you will overflow with thankfulness. (Colossians 2:7 NLT)

If Asked When to Give Thanks, My Answer is:

“In all circumstances.”

Be thankful in all circumstances, for this is God’s will for you who belong to Christ Jesus. (1 Thessalonians 5:18 NLT)

“In plenty and poverty.”

I know how to get along with humble means, and I also know how to live in prosperity; in any and every circumstance I have learned the secret of being filled and going hungry, both of having abundance and suffering need. I can do all things through Him who strengthens me. (Philippians 4:12-13)

Emerson Eggerichs, Ph.D.
Author, Speaker, Pastor

Questions to Consider

  1. What was your total score, and which group did it place you in? Does that match how you would have described yourself before taking the assessment?
  2. Which of the ten statements did you rate lowest? What do you think is behind that rating?
  3. Emerson suggests the ambivalent, lukewarm person may be in a darker place than the reluctant one. Why might indifference be harder to see in ourselves than resistance?
  4. Who is a godly, wise person you could talk with about what you discovered, and which one to three areas from the checklist will you work on first?