Become a member and gain unlimited access to content, courses, and webinars.
The Love & Respect

Membership

$249
$199/y

Unlimited Access To All Our Content

Inside The Love & Respect Membership

  • L&R Conference 10 Week Study Included ($149 value)
  • 14 Online Courses!
  • Access over 930+ Articles
  • Weekly Podcast - 270+ Episodes
  • Ask Emerson - 180+ Videos
  • Collections - 18 Curated Topics
  • Devotional - 52 Videos, Prayer, To-Do
  • Webinars Throughout The Year
and more to come...
Return to the homepage
Christian Life
Image duration icon
25
min
Favorite
Favorite
Oops! Something went wrong.
Favorite

Unveiling the Secrets of Why, How, and When to Give Thanks (Part 1): It’s Time to Reimagine Gratitude

Play Arrow
Watch Intro Video

When we stop to think about the many negative situations that kick us in the gut, it can be easy to sour on the idea of being grateful to God. After all, should we not be reluctant or at the very least ambivalent about thanking God amidst the many troubles and traumas in which we find ourselves?

Back in 2004, when my wife, Sarah, was diagnosed with breast cancer, the burdensome question on the table was: Will she live or die? Sarah responded in a way that forever impacted the family. Our middle child, David, in his twenties at the time, asked her, “Mom, how are you dealing with this?” Sarah replied, “I’ve given thanks to Jesus Christ all my life. I have learned to offer a sacrifice of praise.” To clarify what she meant by this, she quoted Hebrews 13:15, which says, “Through Him then, let’s continually offer up a sacrifice of praise to God, that is, the fruit of lips praising His name.” She then continued, “I am giving Him thanks now, no matter the result.”

Sarah’s example and Scripture quote placed our family in a position to answer the question: Would we display an attitude of thankfulness and praise in the face of a potentially terminal diagnosis? Our first concern centered on her treatment and health, but her faith and faithfulness challenged us with what it means to have a deep-seated gratitude toward God regardless of the outcome.

Would we be reluctant or even ambivalent when it came to giving thanks to God in the midst of Sarah’s diagnosis, or would we remain committed—as Sarah was—to offering up a sacrifice of praise no matter the result?

I am pleased to report that twenty-two years later, Sarah, after a double mastectomy and reconstruction surgery, has a clean bill of health! However, it is important to point out that we do not see her praise and worship amidst the cancer as reason for her recovery. That was her offering to God whatever the outcome may be. She convicted us that we needed to learn a holy lesson about how to give thanks apart from the results.

How about you? Do any of the facets below turn you off from showing an attitude of gratitude when feeling unfairly oppressed?

  • Marital: We have chronic marital conflicts, each of us feeling less important to the other as the years roll by, and we do not feel much gratitude heavenward.
  • Financial: We have more month left over at the end of the money than the other way around, and this financial stress not only empties the purse but drains us of praise.
  • Medical: A health issue arises in our personal life or with a family member that leads to sadness, not gladness, as the Lord leaves unanswered the “Why?”
  • Emotional: We have our hearts set on something only to be forced to navigate unmet expectations, which do not produce gratitude but disappointment.
  • Parental: Having young children, we must face the daily grind of sleepless nights, tantrums, and personal doubt about our ability as parents, so giving thanks to God makes no sense at times.
  • Generational: In mid-life, we have so many ongoing responsibilities toward those under us, like our kids, and those over us, like our aging parents, which means little privilege and pleasure, depleting the desire to give thanks.
  • Vocational: Frustrating tension surfaces in seeking to balance work and family, both of which are part of God’s call, so giving thanks to God for such a struggle and angst seems irrational.
  • Theological: When God seems distant and unresponsive, especially with the “Why?” question, there is little interest or incentive to thank the Lord, who remains silent.
  • Demonic: Knowing Satan is real goes without much argument, but when God allows the evil one to attack, and we feel victimized, this undermines gratefulness and thanksgiving.
  • Prayerful: Not much seems to happen when asking God to help endure trials and resist temptations, so giving thanks during these ignored requests seems silly and insincere.
  • Comparative: Each week, something serves as a reminder that almost everyone among family and friends is achieving greater success and income, so to give thanks during such comparisons makes no sense.

How are you doing when it comes to giving thanks in the areas of: marital, financial, medical, emotional, parental, generational, vocational, theological, demonical, prayerful, and comparative?

None of us can deny these negatives. They are indisputable. For some of us, these roll over us like a tsunami. We gasp for air and entertain calling it quits on God. Offering a sacrifice of praise on the heels of a near drowning seems out of touch with reality. “That may be okay for Sarah Eggerichs,” we may say, “but the rest of us do not qualify for sainthood.”

Sarah would ask, though: What if the responsibilities, adversities, disappointments, sadness, and unanswered questions are actually reasons for giving thanks, not reasons for raising a fist to heaven like Job’s wife who demanded of Job, “Curse God and die!”? What if, in the darkness of the mine, thanksgiving enables us to find nuggets of gold that enrich and enlighten us even though darkness remains?

The Bible, while often seen as counterintuitive, actually unlocks the mysteries of gratitude. Within its pages, Scripture reveals the why, how, and when of giving thanks—doing so with certainty, boldness, and command. Inspired reasons, methods, and moments of gratitude come from God. “All Scripture is inspired by God and beneficial” (2 Timothy 3:16). God calls us to reimagine the purpose and power of thanksgiving. I invite you to reconceptualize gratitude and thanksgiving—to unveil (or be reminded of) the secret to giving thanks. His revelation enlightens and guides us.

I. Why Give Thanks? God’s Inspired Reasons

A. Because This Is God’s Will

Give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.

Paul wrote 1 Thessalonians 5:18 about it being God’s will to give thanks. At first glance, that may not seem odd to the reader. However, when we look more closely at Paul’s life as a disciple of Christ, it could be asked, “‘Give thanks in all circumstances’? This is God’s will? Is he crazy?”

You see, Paul routinely experienced beatings and imprisonment. From reading Scripture we learn that, regarding these beatings, many times he was in danger of death, five times he received forty lashes minus one (the number that supposedly prevented death), three times he was beaten with rods, once he was stoned, three times he was shipwrecked—once spending a night and day in the open sea, he was in constant danger of robbers and religious leaders, and he lived many sleepless nights in hunger and thirst. As well, his enemies falsely accused him before authorities, and his friends abandoned him when he needed them.

Either Paul could be perceived as mentally deranged to give thanks in such challenging circumstances, or he was a mature disciple of Christ firmly convinced that giving thanks in all circumstances aligns with God’s will. Embracing the latter perspective, we are encouraged not to forsake reason when following Paul’s example. Instead, he invites us to reevaluate the foundations of gratitude, emphasizing that it is God’s good will. Paul’s gratitude wasn’t a product of warm, comforting circumstances but a deliberate expression of trust and obedience to Jesus.

One episode strikingly captures how this man lived. After he had been falsely accused and beaten by the authorities in Philippi, we read in Acts 16:25, “About midnight Paul and Silas were praying and singing hymns of praise to God.” Bruised, bleeding, and bemoaning, they chose to praise God and give thanks to Him despite the mistreatment and misery.

Paul revealed more about what this meant to him in Colossians 3:16-17: “Let the word of Christ richly dwell within you, with all wisdom teaching and admonishing one another with psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs, singing with thankfulness in your hearts to God. Whatever you do in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks through Him to God the Father.”

Paul offered praise to God in the face of persecution, prosecution, and prison. His life exemplified thanksgiving amidst torment, thrashings, and torture. He consistently sought to express gratitude during times of gloom, grievances, and groanings.

In the ancient city of Philippi, God orchestrated an earthquake as the catalyst for Paul’s vindication. Having previously visited the archaeological excavation that has revealed this prison site we read about in Acts, I can envision Paul and Silas in that prison, obediently praising and giving thanks to God in the midst of their dire circumstances. The earthquake at the moment of thanksgiving serves as a powerful demonstration of God’s might. This incident serves as a mighty reminder that when God wills us to praise Him, He does so with a purpose.

Can you reimagine yourself praying this week, “Lord, regardless of the circumstances, it is Your will that I give thanks. In trust and obedience toward You, I praise you no matter the outcome”?

B. Because of Who God Is

Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good; his faithful love endures forever. (Psalm 107:1 CSB)

David gave thanks to God because He was God!

In Psalm 63, we observe him praising, blessing, and worshipping despite his exile away from the sanctuary of God. He thirsted more for God than he did for water.

God, You are my God; I shall be watching for You; my soul thirsts for You, my flesh yearns for You, in a dry and exhausted land where there is no water. So have I seen You in the sanctuary, to see Your power and glory. Because Your favor is better than life, my lips will praise You. So I will bless You as long as I live; I will lift up my hands in Your name. My soul is satisfied as with fat and fatness, and my mouth offers praises with joyful lips. (vv. 1-5)

When was the last time you looked heavenward on the heels of something good or less-than-good and exclaimed, “I thank You, Lord. You are always good, faithful, and loving”?

The person who grasps the truth about giving thanks recognizes that sincere satisfaction emerges from praising the Lord Himself. In my book The 4 Wills of God, I stress that mature believers find pleasure in pleasing the Lord. “In pleasing You, Lord, I find pleasure.” Thus, there is pleasure in praising and thanking Him, since this pleases Him.

When Sarah offers a sacrifice of praise, she does so from her unwavering conviction in God’s goodness, faithfulness, and love. In that sense, we might assert that to the extent a person refuses to give thanks, they do not completely embrace God’s inherent nature as good, faithful, and loving.

However, as one delves into the Psalms, it becomes clear that these 150 songs express praise and thanksgiving in anticipation of a manifestation of God’s goodness, faithfulness, and love. The sacrifice of praise envisions this.

The next time you encounter a depressed season, as you pass through an unwanted wilderness, turn to the Psalms to be reminded of who God is, and let that ignite a spirit of thanksgiving as you focus on His love, faithfulness, and goodness.

C. Because Gratitude Should Precede Petition

Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything by prayer and pleading with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. (Philippians 4:6-7)

Why do some people start and end their prayers with a petition toward God without letting thanksgiving accompany their requests?

Some are ignorant of this verse but after learning of the truth, they change to include thanksgiving with their petitions.

On the other hand, sadly, some do not change. They are not God-focused but self-focused in their prayers. They do not thank God while petitioning. To them, praising God ahead of time regardless of the situation or outcome is not only odd but foolish. In their view, they know what they want, and they feel God owes them an answer to their demand.

However, as James taught, when an individual prays with impure motives, God will not respond. He wrote, “You ask and do not receive, because you ask with the wrong motives, so that you may spend what you request on your pleasures” (James 4:3). Praying to God to get Him to do our bidding manipulates God, and God will not be coerced.

For this reason, preceding and accompanying a petition with thanksgiving ensures the purity of prayer, helping us discern our motives. Thanksgiving says, “Lord, I thank You despite the situation and outcome. I praise and thank You for being good, faithful, and loving. I thank You because You work all things together for good based on Your wisdom, love, and goodness.” Then a person might pray, “I ask for an opportunity to work extra jobs this next month so I can earn more money to help pay for the tuition of our children’s school.”

The selflessness and godly aim touch the heart of God, and if I were a betting man, I would bet God “coincidently” opens a job opportunity to earn the necessary amount for tuition for the quarter.

It must be pointed out, though, that Paul did not teach in Philippians 4 that God will answer the request as long as we express thanks beforehand. The only promise is that God will impart His peace (4:7). Our petition—what we want—may not align with what Paul described in Romans 12:2 as God’s “good, pleasing and perfect will” (NIV). So, instead of our anxiety being relieved by getting what we ask, our anxiety is relieved by the peaceful presence of God. That peace—which surpasses our understanding—assures us that He hears us even when His answer is “no.”

J. Vernon McGee shared an experience early in his ministry when God slammed the door shut on pastoring a strategic church.

I felt that the Lord had made a great mistake by not letting me go to that church as pastor. Several years ago Mrs. McGee and I went by that church just to see it. It had gone into liberalism. Things have happened there that I’ll not mention. I said to her, “Do you remember years ago when I thought I should have had the call for that church?” She said, “Yes.” Then I said, “I thank God that He heard and answered my prayer the right way—not the way I prayed it.” I can look back and remember how I had cried to the Lord. I told Him how He had failed me and caused me to miss the greatest opportunity I ever had. Oh, I blamed Him, and I found fault with Him, and I actually scolded Him because He didn’t seem to know what was the best for me! He had shut that door so tight that the resounding slam was in my ears for several years after that. My friend, my heavenly Father had answered my prayer, and I am ashamed of the fact that I did not thank Him at the time. My advice to you is this: Instead of saying that God has not answered your prayers, say, “My heavenly Father heard my prayer, but He told me no, which was the right answer.” We are to let our “requests be made known unto God with thanksgiving.” (J. Vernon McGee commentary)

D. Because We Can Through Christ’s Strength

I have the capacity to give thanks through Christ who can give me strength to give thanks.

Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything by prayer and pleading with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. . . . I can do all things through Him who strengthens me. (Philippians 4:6, 13)

Have we stopped to consider our capacity to give thanks? We can do this! We have this ability and opportunity.

By contrast, animals do not give thanks. They do not have that aptitude. Apes do not gather under a canopy of jungle trees to lift their mighty arms in thanksgiving to God. Apes have no such consciousness of God and thus have no rationality and intentionality to pray, praise, and proclaim.

How sad that some are ape-like in daily living in that they act as though they are incapable of offering thanksgiving to God. Though they have the intelligence, knowledge, freedom, and volition to thank the Creator for His love, goodness, and faithfulness, they do not rise above the nature of an ape. Peter warned that we must not be “like unreasoning animals, creatures of instinct” (2 Peter 2:12).

Whereas the animal kingdom will not be held accountable, Paul described a sad reality about humans. In Romans 1:21, he remarked, “For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile, and their foolish hearts were darkened” (NIV).

Let me add, Paul encourages us in Philippians that though we can give thanks, we can ask Christ to give us the strength to do so. We all have weakness and weariness. When he shared, “I can do all things through Him who strengthens,” did he have in mind the giving of thanks? Yes.

How encouraging that I can pray, “Lord, I feel weak and weary from worry and woe. Grant me the strength to give You thanks no matter what. Help me experience Your peace and power.”

E. Because It Evidences Our Growing Faith and Gratitude

Therefore, as you have received Christ Jesus the Lord, so walk in Him, having been firmly rooted and now being built up in Him and established in your faith, just as you were instructed, and overflowing with gratitude. (Colossians 2:6-7)

This is all about our faith in Jesus. Theologians refer to this as the centrality of Christ. In many ways, when we ignore Jesus, not making Him central, there will not be an overflowing of gratefulness.

Paul informed the believers in Rome, “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing by the word of Christ” (Romans 10:17).

Many misquote this verse. They say faith comes by hearing the word of God, which refers to the entire Bible—Genesis through Revelation. But Paul actually said “the word of Christ.” Show me a thankful person, and I’ll show you an individual routinely growing in faith by reading the words of Christ in the Gospels. For example, following Jesus, they thank the Father for hearing them, revealing Himself to those with childlike faith, helping or healing people, and His purpose in suffering.

At the raising of Lazarus from the dead, Jesus thanked the Father for hearing Him. “So they removed the stone. And Jesus raised His eyes and said, ‘Father, I thank You that You have heard Me. But I knew that You always hear Me’” (John 11:41-42). This challenges me with a simple question: Do I thank the Lord that He always hears me, and in my case, regardless of what He decides to do? The Father always responds to my requests: “No,” “Wait,” or “Yes.” As for His listening, He always says that He listens to me; for that, I can derive comfort and always give thanks.

Matthew 11:25-26 says, “I thank you, Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because you have hidden these things from the wise and the intelligent and have revealed them to infants” (NRSV). When I struggle with why some believe and others do not, I can thank the Father for revealing Himself to those who trust Him in childlike faith. Sadly, those who do not pride themselves on their intellect and worldly knowledge. Hubris among intellectuals is ugly in that such people compare themselves to the less intelligent and then conclude they are better. From the comparative, they jump to the qualitative conclusion that they are “somebody.” Others compare themselves to God and jump to the qualitative conclusion that they are “nobody”—yet “nobodies” that He loves and reveals Himself to.

In Luke 17, we read the story of when Jesus healed ten lepers, but only one returned to give thanks. Jesus expects each of us to give thanks for His healing and help. It’s one thing to be grateful in the face of unanswered questions and difficulties, but we are without excuse when we refuse to praise Him for the things that bless us. The other nine lepers acted in an inexcusable manner.

In Luke 22:19-20, we read, “And he took bread, gave thanks and broke it, and gave it to them, saying, ‘This is my body given for you; do this in remembrance of me.’ In the same way, after the supper he took the cup, saying, ‘This cup is the new covenant in my blood, which is poured out for you’” (NIV). Beyond the bread and wine, Jesus would have given thanks—as hard as that was—for the call to give His body and pour out His blood for the world’s sins. He knew of the Father’s purpose in His suffering.

I make a distinction between mouthing thanks and feeling gratitude in our hearts. True thanksgiving emerges from a grateful heart. One of the points I make to parents is that they can command their children to say thank you with their lips to a sibling who helped them with their homework, but they cannot coerce them to be grateful in their hearts to that sibling. Like all of us, children are moral and spiritual beings who must internalize appreciation and gratitude. Said negatively, they can be told to say “thanks” to a brother but inwardly be so preoccupied with a new toy that they don’t even see the brother standing there or know what they are mouthing. They parrot the parent’s words as they hold the monster truck mesmerized and delighted.

The same applies to God. Jesus quoted Isaiah when He said, “This people honors Me with their lips, but their heart is far away from Me. And in vain do they worship Me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men” (Matthew 15:8-9). We refer to this as lip service. Technically, we can mouth to God, “I give You thanks,” but our hearts are not into it. Our hearts are far away from God.

Not only does the giving of thanks show that we are growing in our faith to Jesus Christ, but we are deepening our heartfelt gratitude.

F. Because It Leads to the Experience of God’s Peace

Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus. (Philippians 4:6-7)

As I referenced earlier, the promise is not that God will fulfill the request we make of Him in prayer with thanksgiving but that He gives us His peace that surpasses all comprehension, and which guards our hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.

It is difficult to comprehend how this peace comes to us. This peace differs from the peace with God, due to forgiveness and reconciliation. Here we experience “the peace of God.” I suppose many asked Paul, “Explain how God imparts His peace so that you experience this subjective peace in your heart and mind.” He informed those making such inquiry that it “surpasses all comprehension.” God’s peace is “deeper than all knowledge” (BBE), “no one can completely understand” (CEV), “beyond anything we can imagine” (GW), and “transcends all understanding” (NIV).

Paul used a military term about this peace that the Amplified translates: “shall garrison and mount guard over your hearts and minds.”

J. Vernon McGee wrote, “Peace came when my heavenly Father let me have cancer. I went to the hospital frightened to death, and then that night I committed it all to Him and told Him I wanted to know He was real. He made Himself real and that peace that ‘passeth all understanding’ flooded my soul. I don’t know how to tell you what it is; I can only say that it is wonderful.” He shared that he entered with worry and came out in peace. In between, he prayed with thanksgiving, but he did not know what would happen insofar as with his cancer. He only knew peace flooded his soul in the meantime.

The Bible tells us that we have the peace of God because the God of peace is with us. Paul went on to write in 4:9, “Whatever you have learned or received or heard from me, or seen in me—put it into practice. And the God of peace will be with you” (NIV).

How do we get this peace? Bring the prayer and supplication before God with thanksgiving, and it is during that petition and praise that peace comes. How? As one friend used to say, “Beats the tar out of me!”

II. How to Give Thanks? God’s Inspired Methods

A. By Praying

Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus. (Philippians 4:6-7)

Here is a prayer I suggest:

Lord, You know my prayer. You know my supplication. You know the issue causing me anxiety. I lift the matter to You, telling You what I desire. However, I do so with thanksgiving. I thank You that You will answer my petition with a yes, no, or not yet. I believe this. Regardless, I give thanks for who You are and what You will do. I thank You despite my past, present, and future circumstances. If I could be so bold, would You, the God of peace, impart Your peace to me when I hear Your yes, no, or not yet? What’s the point of getting what I want and not having Your peace? What’s the point of You saying no or not yet and not having Your peace? No matter what, would You graciously guard my heart and mind with Your peace?

B. By Focusing on Christ, Which Strengthens Faith and Overflows with Thankfulness

…rooted and built up in him, strengthened in the faith as you were taught, and overflowing with thankfulness. (Colossians 2:7 NIV)

The apostle Paul was telling the believers at Colossi that as they grow in Christ by keeping their eyes fixed on Jesus, at some point they overflow with thankfulness. Why would they not? He is the Lord of lords and King of kings, the Alpha and the Omega; He lives within our hearts; He has adopted us into the family of God; and He has made us fellow heirs with Him. How can thanksgiving not overflow?

III. When to Give Thanks? God’s Inspired Moments

A. In All Circumstances

Give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus. (1 Thessalonians 5:18 NIV)

First Thessalonians 5:18 is translated in the Amplified, “Thank [God] in everything [no matter what the circumstances may be, be thankful and give thanks], for this is the will of God for you [who are] in Christ Jesus [the Revealer and Mediator of that will].

Kirk Cousins, then quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings, tore his Achilles tendon in a game during the 2023 season. The injury ended his season, which had held the potential for a great playoff run.

How did Kirk navigate these circumstances? In its November 17, 2023, edition, the Star Tribune quoted Kirk as saying, “I’ve had my fist up a little bit in my prayer times with God.” The answer, he’s realized, is holding his career loosely. “I have played this sport feeling like I don’t own this career. I’ve just got to steward it. And that’s always helped me, because it is chaotic and curveballs do get thrown at you. When you hold it really tightly and say, ‘This is mine,’ that’s when you can get yourself in trouble. And so I’m learning to play the sport holding my hands open and saying, ‘God, whatever you want to do, if that means a torn Achilles, I’ve got to accept that.’... You kind of have to check back in five years and say, ‘What happened?’ Until then, you’re just on the journey.”

Contrast Kirk’s attitude and response to his injury with what the Washington Times reported just five days earlier when USA women’s soccer superstar Megan Rapinoe suffered the same injury. “As far as soccer star Megan Rapinoe is concerned, her Achilles injury in the final game of her storied career comes as evidence that there is no God. Rapinoe, 38, was forced to leave the National Women’s Soccer League championship game Saturday after injuring her right leg, saying afterward she was ‘pretty sure’ that she tore her Achilles tendon. Her team, the Seattle-based OL Reign, lost 2-1 to the NY/NJ Gotham. ‘I thought about it a little bit. I mean, I’m not a religious person or anything, and if there was a God, like, this is proof that there isn’t,’ she said at the press conference following the game. ‘This is f—-ed up’” (November 12, 2023).

It must be asked: If Rapinoe had finished the game victorious and in good health, would she have thanked God and testified to the world that this is proof of God’s existence? Of course not. The mouth speaks out of what fills the heart. Sadly, in response to her injury, she revealed what she believed already, at least to that point in her life.

We must decide how we will journey through less-than-favorable circumstances. The clear admonition in Scripture is to give thanks, for this is God’s will. Paul never interpreted that as fate but as aligning oneself with the love of the Father and thanking Him that He will work all things together for good (Romans 8:28).

As we wrote earlier about Paul’s hardships, it bears repeating here. We are to praise God in persecution, prosecution, and prison. We are to give thanks in the circumstances of torment, thrashings, and torture. We are to be grateful in the circumstances of gloom, grief, and grievances. These are alliterations to capture the emotional struggle most feel during setbacks and suffering. Like Kirk, we too can confess, “I’ve had my fist up a little bit in my prayer times with God.” However, Kirk did not maintain that defiant posture nor claim God’s nonexistence. Instead, he prayed, “God, whatever you want to do, if that means a torn Achilles, I’ve got to accept that . . . I don’t own this career. I’ve just got to steward it.” This is not pie-in-the-sky teaching. This is because Jesus Christ is alive, has spoken, and is sovereign over all circumstances.

B. In Plenty and Poverty

I know how to get along with humble means, and I also know how to live in prosperity; in any and every circumstance I have learned the secret of being filled and going hungry, both of having abundance and suffering need. I can do all things through Him who strengthens me. (Philippians 4:12-13)

We have the privilege of knowing Kirk and his whole family. He and his wife, Julie, have even attended our Love and Respect Marriage Conference. Having been one of the highest-paid athletes in the NFL, Kirk has shown that in living in prosperity, he is learning the secret of giving thanks not only for plenty of money but also for plenty of misery. He is one injury away from an ended career and knows there are no U-Hauls behind a hearse. He cannot take his monetary wealth to heaven. Even in abundance, he must do everything through Christ who strengthens him.

The apostle Paul teaches us that giving thanks is independent of the events around us, whether in plenty or poverty. Harvard law school graduate Sam Erickson, who later founded Advocates International, would celebrate when the courts ruled in his favor. Stunningly, though, he also celebrated when the courts ruled against him. He praised and worshipped whether he had a lot or a little, whether he won or lost. When a matter really mattered, he gave thanks no matter the outcome. He lived above the circumstances.

The extremes of abundance and scarcity can endanger us. We read in Proverbs 30:8-9, “Give me neither poverty nor riches, but give me only my daily bread. Otherwise, I may have too much and disown you and say, ‘Who is the Lord?’ Or I may become poor and steal, and so dishonor the name of my God” (NIV).

A problem can arise when thrown into the waters of extremity. How easy it would be for Kirk to say, “I don’t need God because of my wealth.” But Kirk chose not to disown the Lord but to go a step further in reminding himself that he is not the owner but the steward. He would trust the Lord and give thanks regardless of the abundance or adversity. He revisited the question: Who is the Lord?

In high school, he broke an ankle, which undermined in his heart the potential for recruitment to play college football. He learned to apply Proverbs 3:5-6, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart and do not lean on your own understanding. In all your ways acknowledge Him, and He will make your paths straight.” No matter the circumstances, whether in plenty or poverty, Kirk chose to trust, which is why he gives thanks no matter what. He learned that when he was seventeen years of age—when he had no money and no idea of the future God had in store for him.

One of my best friends, B.J. Weber, served as the chaplain for the New York Yankees. As a man’s man, he spent countless hours with some of the greatest athletes alive, and one of his main messages was: “You are one injury away from an ended career—who then will you be?” That they had wealth dimmed compared to the potential of not having health. We all must step back and ask: “What would cause me to stop giving thanks to the Lord? Too much of what I want? Too little of what I need?”

Emerson Eggerichs, Ph.D.
Author, Speaker, Pastor

Questions to Consider

  1. Of the areas Emerson lists (marital, financial, medical, emotional, parental, generational, vocational, theological, demonic, prayerful, and comparative), which one most tempts you to hold back thanks right now? Why that one?
  2. Sarah said, “I am giving Him thanks now, no matter the result.” What would it look like for you to offer a sacrifice of praise in a situation where you do not yet know the outcome?
  3. Philippians 4:6-7 promises God’s peace, not that we will get what we ask for. How does that change the way you pray about the thing causing you the most anxiety?
  4. Kirk Cousins learned to hold his career with open hands, as a steward rather than an owner. What are you holding tightly that you need to open your hands to God about?